We all know education needs to change, and far too many students leave school without a degree. But even when they do graduate, have we really prepared them for what comes next?
Dr. Kevin Fleming, founder and CEO of Catapult, spent his career in higher education, moving from faculty to dean to VP. At one graduation ceremony, he asked each student, “What’s next?” Their answers changed the course of his career.
Gary and Kevin explore how to prepare students for life beyond graduation, how a meaningful goal can reignite the desire to learn, and why lasting change requires rethinking both the mindsets and the measures that shape our institutions.
—
Listen to the podcast here
Graduation Isn’t Enough With Kevin Fleming
We all know that our systems of education need to change. We know that far too many leave school without a degree, but even when students do graduate, we rarely stop to ask, have we really prepared them for what comes next? Welcome to another episode of the show, where we explore the hidden logic that enables ordinary people to accomplish extraordinary things. My guest is Dr. Kevin Fleming, the founder and CEO of Catapult. A professional learning community that helps educators better prepare students for life.
Like many of my guests, Kevin never set out to become an entrepreneur. He was building a career in higher education, moving from faculty to dean to VP. Yet he kept encountering a problem he could not ignore. Students were earning credentials without a clear sense of who they were, where they were going, or how their education would help them get where they wanted to go. His defining moment came during a graduation ceremony.
As he congratulated each student, he asked them a simple question, “What is next?” The answers they gave him changed the course of his career. While some had clear plans, most had only a vague idea, and far too many had no clue at all. These were the students the system deemed to be successful. Yet their uncertainty about the future challenged his understanding of what success really meant. That was the moment he decided something had to change.
In this conversation, we explore what it means to prepare students for life beyond graduation, how a meaningful goal can reignite a desire to learn, and how Kevin turned his frustration into an idea that is making a real difference. We also discuss why lasting change requires us to rethink both the mindsets and the measures that shape our institutions. Without any further ado, I hope you enjoy my conversation with Dr. Kevin Fleming.
Everyone, I want to take a quick moment to tell you about my new book, The Entrepreneurial Mindset Advantage: The Hidden Logic That Unleashes Human Potential. For nearly twenty years, I have traveled around the world interviewing everyday entrepreneurs. Not the big names, but the underdogs and the misfits who start with little or nothing, yet somehow manage to succeed. What I discovered is that their success is guided by a common and predictable pattern of underlying values and taken-for-granted assumptions of which they themselves are largely unaware.
What I discovered is a hidden logic that can empower ordinary people to accomplish extraordinary things. In this book, I combine insights gleaned from hundreds of everyday entrepreneurs with motivational research to create a practical how-to guide, one that not only shows us how to be more innovative and entrepreneurial in our own lives, but also how to unleash the untapped entrepreneurial potential in others.
Ultimately, the entrepreneurial mindset advantage looks beyond new venture creation to expose the entrepreneurial mindset as a teachable framework for thinking that has become essential for individuals, organizations, and communities to adapt and thrive in today’s rapidly changing world. The Entrepreneurial Mindset Advantage: The Hidden Logic That Unleashes Human Potential is now available wherever books are sold.
—
Kevin, thanks for being a part of this show. I am really looking forward to having this conversation with you.
This has been the highlight of my weekly schedule. I am excited, Gary.
We were introduced through Kathy Boyd, who is also a very innovative and entrepreneurial educator, a mutual friend. What I want to start with is that I know a little bit about your background and the work you are doing. We talked offline a few weeks ago. I want to just start by saying what excites me the most is an entrepreneurial educator. That is what really gets me excited. That is what I am looking forward to in this conversation. The entrepreneurial component of your story, how did that start?
Accidental Entrepreneurship: From Higher Ed Leadership To Unlocking Change
That is actually a harder question for me because I did not recognize it or plan for it. It happened. It was organic. As I go back, I was not the guy who had the lemonade stand or my own lawn-carrying business or something as a youth. I do not think my interest in entrepreneurialism started young. It was not something that I always had, like maybe many entrepreneurs have. For me, I went into education. That was my field. I wanted to change people’s lives. I wanted to harness intellectual prowess. I went into four-year and then community college, and I was climbing the ladder faculty dean, vice president.
My entrepreneurial drive kind of grew over time out of, really part of it was a necessity and part of it was out of frustration, I guess is maybe the answer as I think about how to answer it. The necessity was that I was in a subsegment of higher education that is called career and technical education that really focused on preparing students for work, not just preparing them for graduation. In that sector, which I know you are familiar with a fair amount, Gary, there are a lot of grants. You have to, like, raise your own money. You have to write for grants, and you manage the grants.

Beyond Graduation: My entrepreneurial drive grew over time out of necessity and frustration.
Professionally, I grew up in an environment that had to seek external resources, be persuasive in getting those resources in writing grants, manage the work plan, and grow your staff on your own dime. I was in a department that never had multiple institutions in the same type of department, I should say, that did not just receive a budget. I had to find it and create it and work for it and hustle for it. Over time, that grew a little bit of an entrepreneurial acumen where I felt like I had to build. I did not just inherit.
The second side of that, or the flip side of the coin, pick your metaphor, is that frustration with the system at large that I saw was not working for most students. Over time, I grew a desire to change the system and to change the way we were doing it. Currently, technical education is a minority of the headcount of a lot of institutions. Whether it is two years or four years, the liberal arts or the general education pattern is the majority of enrollments. Career of vocational tech, that is like the minority. I was also colored by all those experiences. I was in this.
It is now the soup de jour, and it is far more popular now. When I started over twenty years ago in that segment, it was the redheaded stepchild that never really got the accolades or the front-page news that it is getting today about apprenticeship and work-based learning and world readiness and the like. For a long time too, I developed almost a healthy chip on my shoulder where I felt like I always had something to prove and I had to get resources. I am this minority voice. I am advocating for a message that does not resonate with a lot of folks in my sector.
That is, focusing on the transformation of the institution. When you mix all those ingredients into the stew, you get an entrepreneur, but I never sat down and said, “I am going to build a business. I never got funding to build a business plan.” It always happened organically on the side while I was doing the best job that I thought I could do in education. That is probably as clear of an answer as I can reflect on it.
That is super interesting to me, Kevin, because it aligns so much with what I hear from entrepreneurial people. First of all, I cannot tell you how many conversations I have with entrepreneurs that start with some form of what you just said, which is essentially I have never thought of myself as an entrepreneur. That in and of itself is fascinating to me. It supports a deeper theory that I have that non-entrepreneurial behavior is learned. That we are hardwired to want to contribute in some meaningful way.
We are not just hardwired to do repetitive tasks in exchange for a paycheck. Something else you also said that I wanted to double-click on, two things, really. One is that the circumstances in which you found yourself forced you to be entrepreneurial. Let me just say how I define that. I define entrepreneurial very simply as self-directed value creation as opposed to other-directed value creation. I like that simplicity because it does not really matter who is writing the check, technically, whose name is on the building. It is just like a mindset. You are learning how to eat what you kill, essentially.
No, I love the definition because I think historically, as I would learn about leadership, I would learn about management, but I never learned about entrepreneurship, like as a field of study or thought process. I would do a lot of leadership development stuff in my fraternity, in graduate school. Went to the Drucker School of Management, the thought in Claremont about management as a field, as a study.
I always differentiated the two leadership versus management, but not until my mid to late 30s that I even really thought about entrepreneurship as like a third or different perspective of that. I thought it was always just like leadership and management. Those are the two sides of the coin on how to be anything. It is funny. I like your definition of being driven because, as I reflect back, I was always driven, but I was not always driven entrepreneurially. I was always driven.
The other component here that is sort of in the soup, and the Kevin Fleming soup, we will call it, is dissatisfaction with the status quo. There is a sense of efficacy in the individual that is already there. That is really important. Again, I am a mindset guy. Efficacy, we are not really conscious that, like, “I have an internal locus of control and an external locus of control.” We are not really constantly aware of those things.
You develop some sense of efficacy in your career, in your role, in your life. You find yourself in some situations like dissatisfaction with the status quo. To me, what is so interesting is the decision like, I am going to try to fix it. It is like the dog is getting shocked in the cage. As one dog tries to escape, the other one will just lie down or whimper. It is that. That is super interesting to me.
I felt screwed, if I could be just super candid. When you feel wronged, or you feel screwed, it is like it becomes personal. You want to right the wrong. It did not start out with like this carrying a banner of social justice or anything, but like I went through a certain education and career trajectory and I felt like I got misled by them and “whoever they are,” the system, whomever, conventional wisdom, whatever you want to describe it as well intended people all along the route, parents, counselors. That made it personal. It is like, I want to fix this, because I did not, I guess, at the core, I did not want other people to have to experience the same pains that I had to go through.
I feel that there is also a lot of what drives me. I was a horrible student, and I thought I just was not very bright, and I did not like learning as it was presented to me. When I became an entrepreneur, I figured out I loved to learn. I am coming at this thing from a similar motivation. You and I talked a couple of weeks ago, and you were saying something like this increasing or growing feeling that something is not right. I am overgeneralizing. Maybe you just touched on it. You talked about a moment at a graduation when you were having these, like, 30-second conversations with graduates. Can you talk to me about both of those components? You felt like you were misled, like that is happening in the background.
That is a great story. I am glad you remember that. For my story, there is a personal piece, and there is a professional piece, obviously. All of us are three-dimensional human beings. We are more than our business cards. We are at risk of oversharing. I will start with the personal side first, and then I will tell the graduation story if that is okay. Growing up, my dad was in the army, did not graduate with a degree, and I was in, I want to say it was like eighth or ninth grade, and he got let go from his engineering job. I saw my dad unemployed.
He was an electronics engineer, working for a keyboard company. He would like to travel abroad, selling keyboards and all that. When I was in middle school, well, then he lost his job, and he became a limo driver. He did a bunch of just odd jobs, and I saw him struggling, and I saw him trying to respect and still respect him now for doing whatever he needed to do to provide for his family. Wife and two boys. He did the things, but I saw him struggle. In the back of my cognitive identity was this, I never want to struggle like I see my dad struggling. What I heard from the world was that he did not get his degree. Maybe if I get a degree, I will not struggle.
Bundled with that was that I saw my older brother, three years older than I, he graduated high school, went to community college, stopped out, had all these odd jobs, and he was struggling. My only two male real examples in my life, in my household, and they both were struggling with careers, and neither of them finished their degree. I had this. My only two never sat down to be clear and said this to me, but I had this, I guess, just a self-created belief from, and there are all these inputs from the external world.
That says, “I get a bachelor’s degree, you will be successful.” Back in the nineties, that was the common narrative. I said, “I got to go into higher ed then and get the degrees because that will prevent me from experiencing the pain that I am seeing in my father and my brother.” That was always kind of the subtext, I think. That is why I thought, “If one bachelor’s degree is good, then I will get two.” I became this academic overachiever, getting multiple degrees. There is the personal side that I have to acknowledge. Honestly, she is like a fire metaphor. That was the strike on the kindling that initiated my drive.
My drive for academia and for the profession was from seeing these people I loved not being overly successful initially at that time. I acknowledged that that is a part of who I am. That is the personal backstory side. Now, to your actual question, though, although that colors it. Now, fast forward, I do multiple degrees. I climbed the education ladder. I am a vice president of a college. COVID happens. We canceled graduation in 2020. This story takes place in the spring of 2021, one year later. I am a vice president of a community college. I want to honor and celebrate with our students who got their certificate or their degree, but we are still social distancing in Southern California at the time.
We did something like a parking lot graduation ceremony. In the spring of 2021, we invited back both classes, the graduating classes of 2020 and 2021. We had over 500 people participate in this ceremony. They would come into the parking lot and park the car with their parents. They would go to one and check in with Gary. Ten feet over, they go to the second easel to get their honor cords and the diploma cover. Normally, my job at commencement is just to stand on stage and applaud as the names are read and the students are whizzing by.
In this particular case, my job that day was to stand at the beginning of a red carpet, and I would just hold the students for like 10 or 15 seconds while the preceding student went down the red carpet, was applauded and celebrated by faculty, took a picture with the president, the chancellor, and then went on to the next station. Everyone has a kind of social distance in this process. I had ten seconds or so with every student. I found myself thinking it was awkward to stand there in perfect silence with somebody for a few seconds.
The Graduation Ceremony Awakening: Recognizing A Broken System
I found myself having just this open-ended, short, encouraging conversation. I would just look at every student, and I would say, “Congratulations, what is next?” It is a community college graduation. The most common answer I got was, “I am transferring.” Which I would say, “That is fantastic. Where are you going?” I would add, “And then what?” I got a bunch of non-answers. I got a bunch of, “I do not know yet. I got a lot of it figured out then,” but they had, like, the next step in their mind. That was about half of the graduates that day. There are 250 or so grads. Half of them had a really clear answer. I would say, “Congratulations, what is next?”
Gary would say, “I have got a job. I have a business, I am working for the family business, or I am doing this to be an example for my kids.” Whatever, they had a reason for what they were getting the certificate or degree for, and they had a real next step. I am getting a promotion, I have an apprenticeship, whatever it is. It was the last quartile, the last fourth, roughly, and I say roughly, I was not keeping track. This just organically happened. About a quarter of the graduates that day, I said, “Congratulations, what is next?” They just looked at me, and they had no answer.
You know when you can see multiple emotions in someone’s eyes? I saw excitement because it was graduation day, but I saw fear. I saw jubilation and, like, complete anxiety because of trepidation. These are the successful ones. It is graduation day, and people are asking them, “What is next? What are you going to do?” Too many students that day. About a quarter had no idea. I remember going home that night, and I was talking to my wife, and I said to her, “Babe, I feel convicted right now because out of half of the students that graduated who have a next step of transferring, they did not have an answer after that. A quarter of the students had no answer even for tomorrow.
That is 75%. Only about a quarter of the people had any kind of a real, clear answer about life, career, whatever, response, but a majority of the college graduates did not have a clear answer of what they were doing next. I felt that I had failed them.” I know the numbers. I know that that is for most community colleges in America, less than a third of the registrants actually complete. I am doing the math in my head. I am saying, “Wait a minute, these are the successful third and three-fourths of them who do not know what they are doing next. That is not counting the other 70% that came to college that did not even make it to graduation.”
I am sitting there like, we are failing. In my definition of failing, I would define that in this scenario as not having a really clear trajectory or next step moving forward. We are failing, like over 80%, 85% of students. It is not working. It has been multiple years now, but that was a very clear, definitive moment in my life when I just took stock of it, and I said to myself, I am complicit in the system that is failing a majority of students. What the hell am I doing? Not because it is the system’s fault, and not because the system is bad, and not because my colleagues were not brilliant and passionate. Quite the contrary.
I worked with a lot of amazing, passionate educators, but we were in this K through 16 structure where the successful ones did not know where they were going. Did not have the clarity of the next step. They did not have the confidence to know where they were. From my view, they did not have the competitive advantage to then be successful in whatever the heck they were going to do next. I felt like I personally, as a leader of this organization, was failing all these kids. There are a lot of other inputs. There are a lot of other anecdotes or stories or conversations along the way that are like a pinnacle a-ha moment, I guess I had. It is not like it was the first time I ever realized.
It is not like I did not realize. It is not like I thought we were always successful with every student before that or anything. Do not get me wrong. It was just so stark and clear because I never had a chance to talk to 500 college graduates before. Even that really quick interaction. Now, all along the side, I was doing keynote speaking. I was doing my authorship, like your keynote speeches. My work was going. At that point, I said, I have got to do something different and really dig into how we make education relevant for these students and stop this blind, again, well-intentioned belief that just getting a piece of paper is going to help them. That shaped the last few years of my life.
That was really that moment of, I do not want to call it clarity, but just that moment of, maybe we will just call it clarity when I said, “I just cannot do this anymore. I can no longer keep doing this as well-paid as I was.” I was “successful,” degrees and a job and a pension and all of that. I saw too many students replicating the mistakes and the pain that I had felt before. I just did not want to do it that way anymore. I wanted to fix it.
De-Risking Innovation: Micro-Experimenting In The Margins
That is so fascinating. I am listening to you. First of all, I just applaud you for having the courage to do that. There is another common theme in your story, Kevin, and that is that like most entrepreneurs do not just jump out, quit their jobs. They are already experimenting in the margins. That was going on in the background, if I hear you correctly. You had this official role, your well-paid pension benefit. You got job security, but you are side hustling, for lack of a better term.
I was always doing things like speaking and facilitating on the side. My first paid speaking gig was in 2001. For decades, I had always had the side hustle, and it was extra income. For a long time, it was super passive. When I used to speak for local groups, my speaking fee was a cold Diet Coke when I started. Again, it was not a business. I was just doing it for the love of the game, just to talk about education and to help. I started with student services and with Greek affairs, and then it evolved into professional development for educators and counselors. My speaking fee for years was a cold Diet Coke. There was actually one partner who said, “That is not fair, Kevin. No, I am paying you. I insist that I pay you, and I did not even know what to charge. I am going to pay you $500.”
I was like, “Okay.” “Send me an invoice.” I was like, “How do I do that?” I fell into it. Like, “I figured that out.” A couple of years later, I guess I will set up a separate checking account, but I never marketed until actually 2021, like I never put out a newsletter until after this and realized, “I have really got to be serious about how to do this outside of my regular gig. It grew organically, but you are right. I always kind of had this, but it was extra. It was not. I did not need it to pay the mortgage. I did not jump into the abyss because I always thought that entrepreneurs took the leap of faith. They quit something, and they jumped in.
The big risk.
That was not my story. You are actually validating. I did not know this. The majority of entrepreneurs are not that way. Do most of them have that side hustle?
In my book, I did a little bit of research on this, and there is considerable data showing that experienced entrepreneurs are actually more risk-averse than non-entrepreneurs. The myth of the entrepreneur as the risk taker is largely that. It is a myth. It is their micro-experimenting in the margins. They are derisking an idea. They do not just quit their jobs, mortgage their homes, and go in on a lark.
That resonates. I then fit that uncommon narrative.
I love this story. It is a typical entrepreneur story. I never thought of myself as an entrepreneur. I found myself in circumstances where there was some untenable thing, a problem I just needed to solve or could not live with. For some people, Kevin, that is poverty. For other people like you, it is just like I encountered a problem that I feel compelled to try to fix.
No, it is funny you say that. Over the years, I have had a lot of friends or colleagues come to me and ask me things like, “How do I know when I should quit my job and do the side hustle?” I would always say, “I do not know because I have not done that yet. I saw that I am still working full time.” I was told by people in the field of education. They would tell me, well, you cannot change the system unless you are in the system. Explicitly, they would say that multiple people, multiple times. There was this ethos that you can only advance education if you are in education.
For a long time, as a dean, as a vice president, being in the weeds, it of course gave me credibility. It gave me subject matter experience with what was going on. I falsely believed that. I actually thought, “I have got to stay in it in order to be able to change it.” It was actually just a couple of experiences I had around that same time, 2020, 2021, 2022, when I actually was able to make those bigger shifts outside of my system than my own.
I realized, “Wait a minute, I can actually make more of an impact and solve this problem outside of the system with more tenacity and fidelity and success than within my own system.” I had to rewire. I guess I had to unlearn what I had been told. That in part gave me the confidence then to hop. You are right. It was rather risk-averse. I only did it once I knew there was kind of like an approach and some income coming in before I gave my notice.
It is somewhat miraculous that you had that awareness that I am complicit in something that is not working. Let me just paraphrase it mildly like that. I have been around community colleges to a fair extent over the last 15 or 20 years as an outsider but a consultant. There are a fair number of people who feel exactly what you felt but somehow do not feel like they have the efficacy to do anything about it. They do not have the influence, and it just becomes like grin and bear it till retirement. That is the exciting part of your story.
Breaking Institutional Bottlenecks And Overcoming Educational Status Quo
Our system of education in America, and I will speak broadly, Gary, I would say this is K through 16 with exceptions. The majority of our system is designed to maintain the status quo and to squash entrepreneurialism and innovation. A hundred percent. There are board policies on top of ed code, on top of union contracts, on top of funding cycles, on top of bureaucratic requirements, on top of interpersonal bosses. You have all these layers that make it very hard to be an intrapreneur or an entrepreneur. That people talk about. It is fricking hard. This system is designed to maintain consistency from year to year.
You have to be able to just find, and we can talk more, like there is a lot of strategies around how to do it and like where to start and all that. I believe anyone can make change within their locus of control, even if it is in their classroom. That is important. Even if they are not changing the state laws or something, or the state funding formula, it is still important. You identify what you can move. You get a coalition of the willing, I would call it, and then, then try to advance even some things outside of your locus of control. There is a whole strategy on how to do that, but you can absolutely change the culture of an organization.
That is what I spend a lot of my time doing now with my team at the catapult, but you are right. I have seen that, and I live that. There is this paralysis of, and I have had a lot of people say, “Kevin, I hope someday to be a Dean or a principal or superintendent or a president.” I can affect change. There is this belief that you can only affect change when you get to that, the pinnacle of the board chart. What is fascinating, and I know you have experienced this, is when you talk to those people.
They are at the pinnacle of change, and they are like, “I cannot change anything either.” I had a college president who was like, “I cannot change this because there is the board.” In my case, there are the union contracts and all these other parameters and educational handcuffs that limit the autonomy of even the superintendent or the president in a hired example, or the superintendent or the principal in a secondary example.
There is not even full autonomy or gravitas there, again, with some exceptions. It is a lot easier, of course, to change things if you are the superintendent and you stay there for a long time, or if you are a president or a chancellor and you stay there for a long time and you have the board and relationships with the teaching and faculty leadership. Absolutely, you can make change, and it is easier there than from the middle. That does not mean it is impossible or not important to do from anywhere in the middle of the ranks.
I want to dig into all of this, Kevin, because I think you are absolutely right. I wrote about this in The Entrepreneurial Mindset Advantage book. Here is something a teacher can do in the margins. That is what my first book is about. That is what Ice House is about. There is always some sense of agency you can have, even under the most absurd constraint. What you are saying is interesting. You are not saying there is some conspiracy, like there is a cabal trying to turn people into mindless little employees. What you are saying is there is a complex system that was designed for the last century that has become a machine that is like rolling down the tracks at a hundred miles an hour, and good luck trying to intercept that machine.
I would say both, and actually, not that the cabal is doing anything, but if you historically look at the American model of education we have, we could have chosen a lot of different models, but objectively, the fact is that we adopted the model from Victorian England that was adopted from the Prussians in present-day Germany. That model of education was, in fact, explicitly designed to break the will of the people and succumb to critical thinking and adaptable, entrepreneurialism.
It was designed to create docile, passive factory workers and military front linemen that would not question authority. We do have this American concept of education that was designed to fill factories, not small business development centers. There is a little bit of the historical design. I will not call it the cabal, but we do have a system that was not designed to create entrepreneurs.
We are saying the same things. I say to people, I think it is helpful for people to understand, like, the Industrial Revolution at the time was like an economic, mind-blowing miracle. The idea that ten men arranged in a certain way could make like 40,000 nails or pins in a day. This is not controversial. It lifted huge swaths of humanity out of abject poverty. The way I think about mindset, Kevin, is that mindset is to a person what culture is to a group.
I would agree with that.
What happens is, let me talk about it on the individual level. Once our brains accept any given schema as the correct way to perceive, think, and feel in relation to a problem or situation, our brains automate that schema in order to reduce the cognitive load. It drops beneath our conscious awareness, but it is still driving the outcomes. Do you follow me?
A hundred percent. In education.
It happens at the cultural level. The underlying values and assumptions that are so deeply embedded in our individual collective consciousness, we do not even know they are there anymore.
That is right.
That is what is producing the outcomes. I do not know. That is why I am so excited to talk to you, because I do not think, I mean, if history is any indication, that hotels do not adopt Airbnb. The taxi cab driver does not adopt Uber until he has no other choice. You know what I mean?
Right. Most public schools are not embracing charter schools or home schools or, like Western Governors University, which is doing competency-based education. It is hard for a lot of public universities to embrace that modality because the ethos has been “No, we do it a certain way.” I have had so many like just really clear punctual examples where I will give you an example. I was recently in a room in Los Angeles County, with over 400 superintendents and assistant superintendents in one room. I just asked a simple question.
I said, “Show of hands, how many of you are very satisfied with your district’s policies and the board policies and the rules to the point that you think your system is working well and you would not change anything?” Something to that effect. Not one hand goes up. Of course they all want to change something. We all inherited this culture, this system that now we are part of the machine and advancing, but we know it does not work. Everyone knows it does not work on its face.
That is what blows my mind. Everybody knows it does not work, but like everybody, it seems powerless to do anything about it. Have you seen the Gallup data on student engagement?
Yes.
It is nuts. It is like, how do you have any system? Look, I am no sociologist, but I am pretty sure the fundamentals of sociology are that when you have a thousand people in a system, and 2 or 3 of them are not, like, receiving the outcomes that the system was designed for, you try to help those few people. When two-thirds of the people in the system are failing in the outcomes, you have to look at the system. It seems to me, and I would love to get your take on this, a lot of what is happening today is like all this blame. It is the tablet, it is the phone, it is the parents, it is everything else. I understand those are factors.
The Carnegie Unit Problem: Why Seat Time Distorts Educational Goals
The wise philosopher Jerry Maguire once said, “Show me the money.” For those that do not know, that is not a philosopher, but I am aging myself with a movie reference, but follow the money, Gary. Our funding formulas are rooted around the Carnegie unit and seat time. Everything else is predicated on that. If you ask me, “What is the root cause? What is the thing that is stopping innovation?” It is a Carnegie unit. For those tuning in, and you know a lot of this, the Carnegie unit was founded in 1906. It had one purpose over a century ago.
The whole reason the Carnegie unit existed at the time it was created was to calculate a teacher’s pension, a faculty member’s pension in higher ed. Had nothing to do with student learning. Fast forward, yes, it made sense then and now that the more someone teaches, the more their pension should be. Now that is the way that schools get funded. That is the way schools get their allocation. That is the reporting unit and the mechanism. It has turned into how we establish students’ financial aid, how many units they have to take to graduate to get a two-year or four-year degree, the seat time allocation, how many courses they could take.
That is all organized around an equation that is misused and is over 5 or 6 centuries old at this point. Everyone knows it does not work. When I get in front of groups, I say, “How many of you know that students learn in different ways at different speeds?” That is not our secret recipe. Everyone’s hand goes up like ever. We all know that. We all know that as human beings, we learn, they learn differently. We all learn differently, and we learn some more quickly than others. Our whole educational system is the antithetical approach that says, “No, we are going to assume that based off of your birth date that you are going to be in a grade for a whole year and you are going to learn a certain number of things.”
You do not move on until you are a year older. We have this lockstep industrial factory model design, and obviously it does not work, but it is because of the money. That is a short answer about because of the Carnegie unit, because of funding formulas, that is how teachers’ contracts are written, that is how union contracts are written, that is how states dole out the money to the schools, that is how they proportionally decide what university gets one carve-out of the pie. Until the funding formula changes, nothing else will change.
Until the funding formula changes, nothing else will change. Share on XThere is another dimension of this I wanted to ask you about. Kevin, it is not clear to me that like, the research is very clear on this. Extrinsic rewards, separable rewards, or threat of punishment predictably undermine intrinsic motivation. We know that intrinsic motivation is the most potent form of motivation. We also know that carrots and sticks, punish-and-reward systems, are the most impoverished forms of motivation.
That is well established. I have had this argument with a dear friend of mine, whose wife is a lifelong educator. Back up one step. To me, it is mind-blowing that we are in 2026, and we are putting kids through systems that rely on punishment and reward, which predictably undermine the intrinsic desire to learn. I am arguing with my friend like, “I do not think educators understand that.” What is your take on that?
That is a really good observation in question. I believe, and I think you would agree, that students are smart. People are smart. When they see a discrepancy between a system and an outcome, they pause. This is why we have enrollment and higher education in decline, especially in four-year universities in America. Right now, they are declining. Some community college systems are increasing, by the way. We can talk about why. The reason confidence in enrollment and higher ed generally is decreasing is that educators have seen it as a place where you learn.
Students want job preparation. They want a piece of paper that will give them a career. When you have that chasm or that separation of expectation, I think that affects motivation because students are not motivated now by the extrinsic reward of getting a transcript or a diploma or a degree. They know, and they see, that will not guarantee them the outcome that they seek, which is either financial security or a job.
You are saying something even more profound. You are saying, like, it is bad enough that we are motivating them with a diploma, which is an extrinsic reward. It is a separable reward. I am not interested in the knowledge. I just need that piece of paper. What do I have to do to get the A is the refrain. That is sort of the indicator of the refrain.
That is very common. You go to any school in America, K through 16, and you ask students why they are taking certain courses. The answer will be, “It’s because I have to.” The most common question asked is, “Will this be on the test?” Very few students, I think, especially in higher ed, very few students, there is an opportunity cost to go to higher ed. They are not doing other things. They are not earning money.
Typically, they are investing in this endeavor. Very few of them are doing it because they want to be enlightened, critical thinkers, and more informed citizens. They are doing it because they believe that the outcome of a degree will result in something they actually want. It is a means to an end. They want a career and a job and all that. Now they see that means to an end is not going to get them what they actually ultimately want.
Even the extrinsic reward is gone.
Yes.
There is no reward. It is what you are saying. It is even worse now that they do not see the value in the degree.
Students want job preparation. They want a piece of paper that will give them a career. Share on XStudents are seeing. I got my bachelor’s degrees in philosophy and psychology. I did not want to be a therapist, and I could not get a job at the philosophy company because it does not exist. I am a poster child for getting a really good education, becoming a critical thinker, but not being able to get a job. There are very few job postings out there for philosophy majors. Again, before you get angry emails, yes, it is a good education. Yes, it trains your mind. Yes, it is great. If you want to be a teacher, a lawyer, a debater, or just a more critical thinker. Yes, of course it is valuable.
Again, most students are getting into student loan debt and delaying their careers and their lives because they think there will be a payoff. Now, when they graduate with a diploma, and now they are in student loan debt, that is a whole other dynamic to all of this. Now they have dug a financial hole for themselves. Not even at square zero yet. They are also not able to get the job. Students are seeing their older siblings, their parents, their friends go through this, and they are questioning now, I think somewhat appropriately, then why should I go? If the extrinsic reward is not there, I want to be really clear about what I am saying and what I am not saying.
A degree has value in certain fields for certain people in a certain trajectory. It does not have universal value for everyone, but knowledge is always good. I am a big advocate for just learning, obviously, but there are a lot of ways to learn that are not always attached to a Carnegie unit. Students are figuring that out. We are seeing a resurgence in trade schools, a boom in ministry and theology, and gap years, and a friend’s daughter just graduated. She is doing a gap year for a year intentionally to travel the world and do some different projects.
We are seeing students doing a lot more of that instead of just blindly going on to the local state university to get a degree in something that they do not know yet at a cost that maybe they cannot afford. They are realizing that may not be in their best interest. It might, but they need to maybe figure out where they want to go first. Students are savvy. Now the extrinsic reward is gone. Now they are saying, “What is the intrinsic reward? What do I want?”
Students are asking that not in a selfish way, but in a very self-reflective way. That is positive. Gary, my wife, reminds me I am not, but if we were king of the world, I would have a lot more introspection and self-awareness embedded throughout, especially our middle school and high school years. They know who they are before they graduate. They can help decide what to do next.
Shift The Focus: From “What to Be” To “What Problem To Solve”
I met this fifteen-year-old kid in Mexico. He was at the preparatory school for Tec de Monterrey, which is like the MIT of Latin America. He was in their prep school. It is called Prepa Tec. He was like a junior in high school or something. His mom was misdiagnosed with breast cancer. This kid started figuring out, like, how can I solve this problem like other kids? This will not happen again. He started researching breast cancer detection, came up with an idea, and I do not know the particulars of it, Kevin, but his idea was basically that he figured out how to put breast cancer detection technology into a bra.
That would show up on your phone. There is an app, and if there is something to be done and it is not just for everybody, people like early-stage or whatever, they are being monitored. One of the things this kid told me is I was almost kicked out of school twice, once for poor conduct and once for poor grades, at fifteen. What I am trying to get back to in my long-winded way is Jaime Casap’s idea of, like, stop asking kids what they want to be when they grow up and start asking them what problems do they want to solve and what do they need to learn in order to solve them?
For each, yes.
It might sound like a platitude, but I think that helps folks understand the intervention. I say this all the time in our work, and I have educators come back to me and say, “I did a test. I asked my kids, what do you want to be when you grow up?” Just like measuring the room, like they are just getting kind of mealy-mouthed, pat answers. The vibe in the room was like here and then she asked, “What problems do you want to solve?”
The room comes alive. I do not know where to take it from there, but I want to hear what you have to say about that. The other part of it is that I anguish over it, Kevin. I lose sleep over. How many young people lose interest in learning because of the ways in which it is presented to them? That was my story. Just bear with me for a second here. In the past, let us say in the industrial era, we all accepted that school sucked. You have just got, but if you could get through it, whether it was high school, it was probably eighth grade, you would be okay.
It was like boot camp. You just had to endure.
You just had to endure it. You just, like, everybody knew it sucked. You got through it. If you got to college, great, you are going to have like, you are like the guarantees like this life. Even if you got out of high school, your dad is going to find you a union guy that is going to get you in the factory, you are going to make $150,000 in today’s, you can have a house, a boat and a decent life. The social and socioeconomic impact of producing kids that lose interest in learning is catastrophic in today’s age, where you are going to have to learn, unlearn, and relearn throughout your whole career.
There is a huge disservice that our educational institutions are doing to our young people. It was Ken Gray’s TED Talk, which I think is, it is, or was the number one TED Talk ever viewed. Sir Ken Robinson. Sorry. Ken Gray is another author that I also hold in high esteem. Sir Ken Robinson, I believe he recounts the story of asking students how many uses they can identify for a paperclip.
I will butcher the specifics, but I think like first graders or second graders or third graders could list like a hundred things that you could do the paperclip because everything, “You can make a really big one and slide down it and you can have a foam one and use it on the swimming pool as a flotation device.” The imagination, the creativity is there. In the same study he cites, they went and asked high school and college students, and they came up with like 5 or 10 uses of a paperclip.
That is George Land’s research on creativity. Well aware of it.
That was Ken’s title of his Ted talk is, Do Schools Kill Creativity. That was his whole title of his TED Talk in the premise. Unsolicited recommendation. If anyone listening has not seen this or Ken Robinson’s TED Talk, you should watch it. There is a lot of other research like that that illustrates this fact that we train students to hate learning. Again, I am saying that in a very broad brush, but we train them to only do assignments that are required to do what is required to get a score for the grade. We train them. We teach to the test. They performed the syllabus, and it is sad because there are a lot of students. I just had my niece graduate from high school, and she is like, “I am so glad I do not have to read anymore.”
She says to me, “I am going to take the summer off. I am so glad I do not have to read.” She said that “I knew what she meant. What she meant was, I get a mental break from all the schoolwork, and it is summertime.” There is more to that. She was like, “I am not picking up a book for a long time, as opposed to the pleasure of reading and learning and expanding our mind and discovering the universe and all these finding truth.” My heart of an educator cries when students say things like that, because I think you are exactly right. Our schools are, there is no saying this is what matters is what you measure, and you measure what matters.
We are unfortunately not measuring increasing the love of learning. We are not measuring increasing self-efficacy and self-awareness. We are not measuring helping to fulfill students’ potential. We are not measuring increasing creativity and innovation and entrepreneurial mindsets. What we are measuring is hours that the students sat in a sled desk, Carnegie units, degrees, transcripts, GPA. That is what we are measuring. I just think we are measuring the wrong things.
Restoring Intrinsic Motivation And Joy In Student Learning
Part of what my work is, where our work intersects yours and mine. I wrote about this, like entrepreneurship in education, in my book, The Entrepreneurial Mindset Advantage. It is a simple intervention. What I am advocating, Kevin, is that students starting maybe in grade five, I just sort of roughly say developmentally, they start to understand the world around them in a way that they have the capacity for this. An argument can be made much younger. To encourage students to undertake entrepreneurial, the largest way I can just find that, projects of their own.
What I mean by that is to enable them to find ways to make themselves useful, to pursue things that are interesting to them in ways that are useful to other people. You do not have to break down the system to do that. You can do it in the margins. You can do it before school, after school. It does not require a major overhaul, in my view.
What I want the student to experience, and I have seen it, over the twenty years we have been out there in the world doing this, I get letters from parents, from teachers, I cannot believe this is the same kid. What I am trying to get to, Kevin, is that I want every student to experience learning as a source of joy, as a source of fulfillment, as something like you lean into, you look forward to, hard is the point. Once somebody experiences that, where learning and work and play are indistinguishable. That is how we unlock a deeper dimension of human potential, in my way of thinking.
What you just described is very strongly rooted in the research by Dr. Csikszentmihalyi about flow. When you lose yourself in that endeavor, you do not care what the grade is. You do not care how long it takes you because you are so passionate about it. I know you said that quote earlier from Jaime about not asking students what they want to do, but asking them or what to be, but asking them what problem they want to solve. JP Michel is a career development expert from Canada that took that actually in by Jaime specifically and wrote a book called The World Needs You and really dives into then how do we instill that mindset into students?
I would recommend that to you and others. I have the pleasure of working with him in Catapult Masterclass, and JP is a great guy and talks about how we should be coaching our students and let us work on those problem-based learning activities. Let us do the hands-on work experience instead of ignoring the students’ job, part-time job, like most schools will do and colleges, they ignore the part-time job a student has. Instead of that, how do we embrace it?
How do we leverage it? How do we make those projects that they are working on outside of school matter? How do we make that contextualize into what they are learning in school? I believe if you can help a student identify what problem they want to solve, what things they are passionate about, then all of a sudden the content they are learning in school has relevance and has meaning because now they understand why they need that foundational knowledge because it will help drive them.
JP Michel gives this great example of coaching a student once, and he handed her a copy of The Economist, I believe he did, a couple of different magazines, and said, flip through these. Find a problem you find interesting. She found an article in The Economist about algae and about the oceans. She is like, “I am really interested in how to clean up the oceans? This is a problem she was passionate about solving.” JP recounts how he says, “Great.”
He says, “Let us go online and find out who the people working on this problem are.” In the geographical region where she resided, they found a number of companies that were working on cleaning the oceans. He then went to their About Us page and looked at who the people working in this company were who were working on this problem. He told her to go to the LinkedIn platform, go to their profile, and wait. What was her career trajectory? Where did they go to school? What were their majors in? He saw that a lot of them were getting majors in materials science and some other things. It was given to her by reverse engineering, giving her almost a career path.
Say, “Here are some people to go interview. Here are some majors to think about. Here are some companies to start reading about in researching and maybe applying for internships because people and companies are working on this problem that you are interested in.” All of a sudden, he says, science became interesting, and subjects at school became interesting because then she could connect the dots between what you are learning and what you want to do. That is so simplistic. Anyone tuning in is, of course, “Kevin, that is how you build intrinsic motivation.” How many of our institutions are doing that for students at scale, individualized?
What at the heart of what you are saying, though, is that the desire to contribute meaningfully is innate.
I believe so. My theory is that non-entrepreneurial behavior is learned. A two- year-old is going to say, “I help, I do it. I want to do it myself.” The autonomy, the desire to contribute, those are essential ingredients for human flourishing.
No one bounces out of bed and says, “I look forward to not making a difference today.”
No one looks forward to saying things like, I want to do like repetitive tasks that somebody else told me to do in exchange for a paycheck.
That is why increasingly people are choosing lifestyle over paycheck. They are choosing autonomy and impact over benefits and pension.
There is a third thing here, Kevin. People are, like, quiet quitting, saying they are choosing lifestyle, but they are not contributing. They are just opting out of, like, our parents’ or grandparents’ ethos of, like, keep your nose to the grindstone, be a good employee, you will be rewarded, you will get the gold watch. They opted out of that, and they are phoning it in, and they are taking as much vacation time as they can or quitting or whatever, but they are still not contributing, and they are still not flourishing.
Work ethic.
Most people would agree that it has declined over the last few decades. In large part, because of this, I will call it the university-for-all mentality. We have a lot of students. A personal example, when I was in high school, I was told by Kevin, “Your job is to go to school. My job was to get good grades.” A lot of my peers, and when I was an administrator in higher ed for many years, I would see a lot of students.
They would go through high school, go through undergrad, and never have a job because their parents wanted them to be successful in “academia.” They never even had a part-time job. I cannot tell you how many college graduates I saw launch into the world, and they had zero work experience, zero as a result, zero work ethic. They might have academic wherewithal and acumen, but they do not have work ethic, that grind, that hustle. It is absent.
Can we talk about that for a second, Kevin? That word, like, I have studied enough of human motivation to believe that there is no such thing as laziness. There is such a thing as default helplessness, which Seligman used to call learned helplessness. When people talk about, there is no work ethic, it is that people are not bought into that vision because it no longer I mean, they do not believe it exists.
Value Expectancy Theory: Rethinking Work Ethic And Career Readiness
They do not think, what is that theory that is like a combination of, it is called value expectancy theory. The two things that determine whether you are going to pursue a particular path is to what extent do you value the outcome, and to what extent do you believe you are going to achieve that outcome? When people talk about work ethic, they are looking at this backwards through a lens of, like, “My grandfather, my dad.” They saw that their efforts were going to lead to something. That path is not clear anymore, folks.
I agree, it is not clear. The timeline is very fuzzy for a lot of youth. If we talk about specifically those in their teens or their twenties, I think there is this ethos in America today that says, “Go be an influencer, start a YouTube channel, be rich in six months.” I realize that the average CEO is in his early 50s. They think that there is a shortcut to success. For how many years have you and I seen? I am sure anyone tuning in, “We have all seen those 30-day programs to get rich and multi-level marketing companies, and all kinds of different ways that accelerate.”
Passive income.
There is no such thing as passive income. There are people who think, “All I need to do is follow this person’s seven-step formula and I will be successful by Thursday.” As opposed to, “I need to grind for ten years and really be mentored, be an apprentice under somebody, understand how the field works, learn from their network, observe, help out.”
I was just talking to a recent high school graduate this Sunday after church, and we were talking about how he wants to go into commercial real estate, and he asked for my advice, and I said, “I have never been in commercial real estate.” Said, “I will give you generic advice. I say, “You reach out to people that are doing it.” You ask if you can interview them.
You ask if you can work for them for free to learn. You ask them if you have not evaluated them, if you can do something for them that is paid. Over time, I said, “To be prepared, I told him for at least a year to be an apprentice under him and learn and not expect to make six figures.” I said, “Expect to be poorly paid for another 2 to 3 years to learn underneath him.”
I said, “4 or 5 years from now, if you do that, you might be able to gain.” Asked him, “How long has he actually known someone in his family, like an uncle, that has been doing commercial real estate, been doing it for 35 years?” I said to him, “If you mentor underneath this guy for five years, getting poorly paid and you learn from his 35 years of experience, you will be 30 years ahead of the game five years from now.”
What is fully paid against, like, the $160,000 for a college degree?
That is exactly right, too. They are thinking six figures off right out the gate with no experience. I was telling him, “No, you do it for free to start, and then you do it for a low wage, secondly, because the value you are getting is not in the paycheck. Told him it is in the mentorship and the learning and the life experiences. Here is a 35-year veteran. If they are willing to invest in you and treat, mentor you, train you, and put you under their wing in exchange for cheap labor for a while, that is a huge value to you, even though you cannot deposit it into your checking account. He was not initially thinking of that as having explicit value.
He was thinking more about just the dollars. This goes again to the speed of the grind. He wanted to be successful by next year and two years from now. I am like, “Dude, you are eighteen, but you have this almost unrealistic timeline for success.” That is in part, but I also mean, by work ethic, is it realistic? I love the framework you are articulating. Yes, it is the perceived value, but it is the timeline for which they need to put into an endeavor to understand it, implement it, master it, and then be able to wield that. That does not come overnight for most.
There is also an important component of what you are saying is, you can use a bunch of different words. I hear entrepreneurs say this. I have not gotten it out of you yet, but I probably will before the podcast is over. Here is my thinking. The thing that distinguishes an entrepreneurial person from a non-entrepreneurial person is some sort of a transcendent vision. There is something in the mind’s eye that I am trying to accomplish that does not yet exist. Seligman calls this prospection theory. Most of us, the way a mindset works, Kevin, is it becomes a mindset.
It creates this very powerful incentive to draw from the past in order to navigate the future. From an evolutionary perspective, that is a feature in stable conditions. You do not have to think. You could just go and do and do and do because your subconscious mind is just automatic. That works to your favor in stable conditions, but it becomes a bug in dynamism and change, ambiguity, and complexity. What I am getting at is I know you have one because we have talked offline about it. I know, guess what catapult is, is your vision. That enables you to access problem-solving abilities, deeper levels of engagement, and you are less distractible.
This is a superpower that enables you to get access to your own capacities that are otherwise not available to you. That is just mind-blowing to me. Maybe this ties back to the beginning of the conversation with the students. What we do in our mindset training, in our mindset programs for students, is that it starts with what the future you want to create for yourself. Do not think about the how, how much money you need, what kind of degrees. We are encouraging people to engage in what some scholars call transcendent thinking.
It is encouraging to hear you say that is prevalent within entrepreneurial thinking. It lives obviously outside of that as well. I am thinking about an experience years ago I had where a buddy had a vision board and created it like a binder. They found magazine clippings, and it was like this binder, like this future that they want to have. It was not exclusively just a business endeavor, obviously, but anytime having that North Star and this is the philosophy of Ica guy also, and really like understanding who you are and where you are going.
Absolutely, that has huge importance for personal self-efficacy, for career development skills, for entrepreneurship. I know even in the education world, when I was writing a grant or doing a project, the hardest part, even doing the PhD, my hardest part is refining the research question, being really clear on the objectives of the project, and narrowing it down to just one or two things and cutting out all the noise. That is very hard to do.
There is a lot of noise. I love that. It makes sense that that is prevalent within entrepreneurial thinking. For me, I mean, that is what I realized even back on graduation day in the parking lot in 2021 is that my North Star was, how do we make education more relevant for every student and stop the cookie-cutter approach in the way we are preparing them, because so many of them were unfulfilled and clueless about who they are and not confident where they were going.
My North Star was how do we make education relevant? That word, relevancy, has a lot of research and meaning behind it objectively. Also, for me, you do not have any relevant education experience or conversation without the broader context, without what you say, without knowing where you are going, what problem you want to solve. Who are you? Who are you and where are you going?
Aristotle’s Acorn Theory And Personalizing Student Identity
That is it. Kevin, maybe we can conspire on this over a longer. Paul, I think you could make an impact. The data you share, your anecdotal data from the graduates, with the 500 kids, I think we could make an impact on those kids with a simple intervention like a freshman seminar, a student success, something short, mindset-oriented, just getting students to think beyond career. Who are you? Here is my entrepreneurial theory in a nutshell, Kevin. It is like we are all born with some kind of interest in abilities, gifts, or potential.
Every one of us. It is our job to figure out how to make ourselves useful to our fellow humans with those gifts. As educators, our job is to hand out the Kool-Aid or the Gatorade on the marathon. If we start, we just begin. Specifically, my heart, I have a lot of energy around community college because that is where the misfits and the underdogs show up. We could make an impact if we just started with some transcendent thinking, get people to think about what the future is that you want to create for yourself. There are a lot of resources to support this. This is not just my over-caffeinated enthusiasm here.
Which I share. The caffeinated part especially. In education, there are a lot of different metaphors for how to think about the role an educator has in a student’s life. Some think a student is a ball of clay and the educator is the potter that shapes it. Others think that students are kindling, and it is an educator’s job to light a spark that starts the fire. I have always loved the metaphor that Aristotle wrote. It is called teleology, or you can look up telos. Aristotle wrote that every human being is like an acorn.
He wrote, “Inside the acorn is everything that seed needs to become a great oak tree, but it requires a proper environment, proper nourishment of the soil, watering and sunlight and all the like.” You could take two acorns. One is properly nourished, and it thrives. The other disintegrates if it is not properly nourished. I believe education and our job is really to identify, to your point, the God-given gifts, the aptitudes, the interests, the passions that someone has. How do we identify them and then make sure they are nurtured in the correct soil with the right fertilizer and sunlight and the like?
If a school or a college does its job well, it will personalize every student’s journey in education to ensure it is germane and relevant for them as an individual unique acorn that has a very specific oak tree trajectory in its future and not treat all students as if they are the same because they are not. Even if they are in the same major in the same graduation year, they are not the same, and they are going to go in different paths, and they have different histories.

Beyond Graduation: If a school or a college does its job well, it will personalize every student’s journey in education to ensure it is germane and relevant for them.
We should be honoring who they are, what knowledge they come in with, and be clearer on helping them find their identity so that they can chart their own individual path instead of just saying, “You are all psychology majors, you are all going to get this one degree, you are all going to go do the same thing,” which we know is not true. I share that caffeinated enthusiasm for identifying, and in fact, my next book that is coming out this fall is called Made to Matter. It is really a guide for students, and it is a spiritually based guide about who you are.
What is your identity? How do you think about the world of work given who you are and who you were created to be? Absent any specifics on the job postings or your business card. I believe it is so imperative that we make sure all youth have that conversation about their identity and not allow external bureaucracies or external forces or YouTube videos to define for them who they are, but to ensure they go through that process of reflection, introspection, observation, and the like to really identify.
Again, to your point, not just their interests, not just their personalities, not just their aptitudes, but all of that, because there are different pieces to the puzzle. Too many students are launched out into the world before or after graduation, and they do not know that they have not been through that freshman seminar, that intervention, and a lot of examples exist, but I think you are right. We just need to make sure every student gets something, whatever that intervention is.
The most recent motivation literature is building on Aristotle’s acorn theory that humans are like any other organism have both the desire and the capacity to become all that they can become. This is like Maslow. Is going. What Deci and Ryan, the self-determination theory guys, are saying is that it is not soil, sunlight, and water. It is for an acorn, for a human being, what those three ingredients are is autonomy, competence, and relatedness, which is a clunkier word for, like, purpose. When those three essential ingredients are attainable, lifelong growth, social integration, and psychological well-being ensue.
Here is what is interesting. You take away any one of those three and suboptimus starts to go south pretty quickly. What Deci and Ryan are saying is that then what we do is we turn to need substitutes when we cannot get these essential psychological needs met, autonomy, competency, and relatedness. We look for a new substitute. We buy cars we cannot afford as a proxy for relatedness. We buy the $800 a month BMW we cannot afford that keeps us tethered to the job we do not like. We just get stuck, and human flourishing is thwarted. It is just an expansion on exactly what you just said on Aristotle’s idea.
Gary, are you aware of any school district or college or university that is built around self-determination theory that has, for example, like a core curriculum around like you said around autonomy, competence and relatedness. Are you aware of any model like that? I am not.
The closest I have come is Tecnológico de Monterrey in Mexico. Their mission statement, I am paraphrasing, is that every student graduates with an entrepreneurial mindset, with a humanistic outlook and a global reach. They practice it. I have been a consultant there. I have worked there and lectured there for over a decade. It is the closest thing I have seen.
I like that. In my research, I have looked at purposiveness and relevancy as being a four-quadrant matrix that really helps to find this. I obviously like Deci and Ryan’s approach to it.
Self-Determination Theory: Autonomy, Competence, And Relatedness In Education
SDT, self-determination theory. In my work, that was a big milestone of understanding. I want to come back to, like, your entrepreneurial story here. We have been talking for an hour and twenty minutes. Seems like 15 minutes.
It is gone fast.
My theory of entrepreneurial development is this, Kevin, it is really quite simple. The entrepreneur unwittingly stumbles into that trifecta, autonomy, competency, and relatedness. They flourish. They cannot articulate how or why. That is what is happening. These are ordinary people who find themselves in these circumstances. You are a prime example of it. You have autonomy. You have to make your own decisions. You are in charge of your own life. You have to develop competencies. As you said, you started out.
You had to eat what you killed. You have to figure out how to get grants and how to make it all work. When people are paying you, this is what people miss. When people are paying you for something that you created with your own ingenuity, that is like the deepest form. It is a very human thing. It is a form of validation. It is a form of relatedness. That human being is saying to you, “I value what you created.” The person who articulated this better than anyone I have ever heard is none other than Karl Marx, of all people.
He wrote this in his alienation theory. He said, “What if we could exchange as humans? We would both benefit in two ways.” Let us say I make this thing, whatever the thing is. In the making of that thing, I am expressing who I am. It is from what is in me that is now being expressed, manifest outside of me. I benefit from doing that. I benefit doubly when my friend Kevin Fleming says, that expression of you is useful to me. You and I do that, that is how we both exchange, we both like it is really a recipe for flourishing. I just find it so ironic that it comes from Karl Marx.
The irony is not lost on me. What is interesting too, and we touched on this, but maybe it is another conversation. I am equally fascinated by how we do that for the individual. You mentioned earlier, too. How do we do that for the culture of an organization?
I have done it again and again. It comes back to managerial versus entrepreneurial understanding of the different underlying assumptions and the need for both. It is short, and that could be a second conversation because I will talk to you for two more hours if you will let me. Let us go back to the origin story here, Kevin. You and I are going down the philosophical academic rabbit holes here, which I love to do. Let us go back to the idea where you come home one day, and you just say, like, “I cannot do this anymore.” What is the solution? What next? What did you do?
Entrepreneurial Thinking In Education
I very quickly started to reverse engineer how I have helped other schools and my own college to change perspectives, to change mindsets. I actually then went through a process with an external coach, and they helped me reverse engineer the successes that I had experienced in my side hustle. It turned into a catapult masterclass that we have been leading for years, and it changes mindsets at scale so that counselors, administrators, teachers, and faculty begin to push the goalposts back beyond just graduation. One of my bumper stickers here is how you define the goal always defines how you play the game.
As a student, I define the goal as getting a degree, and you will be successful. I was not. I was underemployed and drowning in student loan debt. As an administrator, I define the goal as we will get more students to graduate. I realized, nope, that does not work either. I realized you actually need to change the goal internally in an individual’s mind, as well as organizationally change the metrics, the mission statement, and the dashboards.
If you can do those things, only changing metrics and mindsets, you can actually change culture. What I ended up doing is sit back and say, “What we are doing is not working. It is failing too many students. How do we change the metrics and mindsets of organizations?” That is what I have spent almost the last decade now doing and building a theory and a professional development methodology around both individually and institutionally. How do we change that? How do we push that goalpost back?
Transforming Institutional Culture By Changing Metrics And Mindsets
We are no longer just preparing students for commencement. We are preparing them for life. I do not like the college and career readiness nomenclature. They have to be world-ready. It transcends and goes beyond commencement or their first job. Some schools are like, “We prepare them for a job.” I said, “That is fine. Then what?” When their interests change, are we preparing them for their third job, for their fourth job, for the 18th job?
AI eliminates that job.
How are we giving them the identity and the tools to then pivot throughout their career? Some schools are like, “We do not do that. We are not measured to do that. We are not funded to do that, or we do not know how to do that. That is where we come in. That is where catapult helps to give them the ideas, but also the support to implement that change. What we have found time and time again is that if you change the mindsets and the metrics, everything else falls in line.
The rest of it is important, but it is noise. You could spend years, and I have done this, creating a very effective program. If you do not have the metrics and the mindsets around that evolving and changing, then the program will either be relegated to that horrible building on the fringe of campus, or it will just die when the grant funding goes away. It is not really changing the ethos of the organization.
What I have become equally fascinated about, and it is funny, is that my next book is about the individual identity of an individual person, the human, but my company is focused on the identity and the metrics and mindset of an organization and a whole institution. Sometimes I feel schizophrenic, but I think both are equally important. We need to talk about both because the theories and the approaches on how to do that are very different, obviously, changing institutional culture versus individual identity and self-exploration work.
I love that, Kevin. I have said as much in my book that I am saying to the individual, “Look, like I want to do cool s***, but the world will not let me.” I am revoking your right to say that. I am taking that card off the table. You have to find a way in spite of the system. That is what Uncle Cleve is all about. This is about an African-American entrepreneur in the Jim Crow South. He is not allowed in the bank, but he has money in the bank.
You have to find a way to be more innovative and entrepreneurial to create value without someone else telling you how to do it, when to do it, where to do it, or why to do it, regardless of the system. I have just shown you countless examples of people who have overcome way worse conditions than you are probably experiencing.
What you just said, I think, is the secret recipe for anyone tuning in like “How do I get started?” or “What do I do? You just said outside of, regardless of the system’s expectations of you. I interviewed a couple of weeks ago, and they said, “Kevin, how did you go from part-time faculty to director and director to dean and dean to vice president?” How did you make all your career moves? My answer, to sum it up, was very simple, “I just did more than my job description told me to do.”
Many of us are like that, and there are even some folks, some smart, well-intended people that are like, “I am going to stay in my box and I cannot or should not go outside of my job description. That is not my job, that is not my lane, like that is outside of my purview.” They think about it in a lot of different ways. The only way I have experienced or seen success or broader impact people have made is if they go outside of their job description and outside of their expectations.
The only way people experience and see success or broader impact is if they go outside of their job description and expectations. Share on XShowing up early, staying late, volunteering, asking for extra assignments, looking for problems to solve, applying for the grant you do not need to, supporting that other institution you do not need to. That is how we grow. What I found is that flywheel that the experience creates the drive that creates the next willingness to raise your hand and volunteer. It is a perpetual cycle, but it is getting started. Many people, I think, need permission. What you just said, you are taking it off the table to give an excuse, taking it off the table that it is not an expectation of the job description or the organization you are in, but do more anyway. Do more in spite of.
In spite of the system. Back to your like person versus situation framing, which I agree with. I am also saying, so I am saying that to the individual, find a way. I just showed you all these examples. I gave you a framework. Go find a way. I am also saying to leaders to stop complaining about the lack of engagement on behalf of your students, your children, your workforce. Look at the systems you have inherited, the systems you have designed, the systems that you oversee, and start to look at the ways in which those systems are predictably producing those outcomes.
Building Sustainable Culture Change With Catapult
That is the person and the situation. It is so powerful. I really love what you are doing here, Kevin. I cannot wait to dig in and learn more. We are just running out of time here. It sounds like what you are saying is that you have designed this master class, like Catapult is a master class of lots of interventions. It is not just some big massive overhaul. We are going to burn down the building and start over. Do I have that right? It is like a constellation of solutions from experts.
I have some colleagues who think we should tear down the system, burn down the building, and start all over. I do not fall in that camp. The baby is worth saving and does not throw it out with the bath water, as the old metaphor goes. I still think we have a great system of education in America, one of the best in the world, but it is misaligned. I do believe there are ways to, it is what we provide are not just the ideas and the methodology for getting galvanized support across the whole organization.
We can get staff, faculty and teachers, counselors, administrators, all singing from the same hymnal and using the same terminology to redefine student success. We have the professional development content, but more importantly, we provide the coaching and the tactical implementation support to get started or to take the next step because so much of it is nuanced given an individual culture, and all schools are the same, but they are different. All colleges are the same, but they are all completely different. Knowing exactly how to take the next step. That is really where the hard work is.
We do provide that individual and that end peer group counseling to identify, here is given where you are at, what your next step should be to increase the conversation, to change the metrics, to change the mindsets, to redefine student success beyond completion. We help both K through 12 districts and colleges and universities do that. It is rewarding, Gary, to see people say the most common thing people say is, “Thank you, guys, for articulating what I have been feeling and being able to put it in a format that others can now join in a conversation to solve this.” We are all feeling the lack of congruity. We are all feeling the lack of alignment.

Beyond Graduation: We all are feeling the lack of congruity. We’re all feeling the lack of alignment. We know there’s a problem with the status quo, and now here’s a roadmap to follow.
We know there is a problem with the status quo. Now here is a roadmap to follow on how to actually change it. I feel very lucky and blessed to be with 50 other catapult speakers that are all like-minded in this, in our whole conversation, Gary, about how do we change this and what are the theories and practices that work. I do think the American educational system is worth saving. I do think there are a lot of, and I know there are a lot of very strong, passionate, intelligent people within our systems, but I equally know they feel that learned helplessness, and they feel trapped, and they feel like the machine will not let them change it.
I have a lot of personal and anecdotal stories of individuals who have experienced it, but then also figure out how to overcome that. I am honored to partner with institutions to change that and to change the dialogue, change the definition of the goal, and truly see every student as that three-dimensional human that deserves the identification of their acorn and the fertilization of their uniqueness so they can become that oak tree. It is just rewarding to see and to see the outcomes then as a result of people who go through a multi-year culture-changing process.
Footnote, it takes multiple years. You cannot change your culture in one semester. It is a series of different interventions cloaked as a professional development program. It is all rooted in research, and it has been. It is a fun journey, and we are not done yet. We are. We still have a lot more to go. Maybe another conversation can dive into more about where it is and where we are going, but I have the honor of leading the group and really making education relevant.
I love it. Kevin, I am going to ask you one question. We will wrap up here. What is it about you that makes this work? What is your superpower?
That is a hard question. You should ask my staff. Ask my team what they say.
You should ask your wife.
To paraphrase Alex Hormozi’s work.
What do you bring into this that is unique that you can do really well?
Part of it, honestly, is tenacity and staying on task. I say that is informed by some other work I am doing related to this, but I have not hopped from this mission or this difference that I want to make in the world of making education relevant. This is, in fact, my 27th year doing the same thing, slight variations, different jobs, different institutions, different shades of gray, and how to do it. I have not wavered. If I were to quit everything and then go start a dental practice, it would be a complete pivot. There is a lot of research around 10,000 hours and the talent code and tipping point and all of that and good to great.
There are a lot of Jim Collins and a lot of folks who have written about this, but I think once you do something for over a decade, and I am now almost approaching three decades, I think that fidelity matters. I do not think I am uniquely positioned. I am not smarter than anybody else. It is not like my resume looks so unique compared to other people’s. I am certainly not the sharpest administrator, author, or entrepreneur in the world. It is that relentless pursuit and consistency of focus.
That might be somewhat unique. Someone said that to me. The reason I answered that to you, Gary, is that someone just said that to me last week, and they have watched my work for a while, and because I am still at it and still refining it and still finding new ways to achieve this mission. Whether it is animated videos, books, plans, consulting, Catapult masterclass, whatever it is, it is all galvanized towards one end goal of helping people identify who they are and where they are going and help them find relevancy in the process.

Beyond Graduation: May there never be a day when the situation and the goal doesn’t impact us. May there also never be a day when our efforts don’t impact the goal.
The short answer would be time on task, brother, and just relentlessly not being willing to let them say, “Tell me that it is not worth the grind and it cannot be done.” I have a little placard on my desk. Ronald Reagan had a little placard on his desk that says it can be done. I have that here on my desk, and it is just a constant reminder that this goal is worth the sacrifice and pursuing. I am not going to give up until we achieve it.
Kevin, thank you. You are just a living, breathing specimen of an entrepreneur. The point that I am trying to make here is that what people who are from the outside do not realize, and you yourself may not realize, is the profound effect the goal itself is having on you. That is, it sent me high. It is the goal acting on the individual. It is like people look at people like you and think, “You just have these traits. You are just passionate. You are just determined.” Those things are true, but those are largely effects. This is social psychology 101. The situation is acting on you.
There may never be a day, Gary, when the situation and the goal do not impact us. May there also never be a day when our efforts do not impact the goal. It is absolutely an iterative process, and I have had to redefine my goal many times, but it is still in the same direction, which is always interesting to me. I appreciate the conversation at times very much, my friend.
This has been a great conversation. We are definitely going to have to do part two. I am going to hold you to that one.
I look forward to it.
Important Links
- Kevin Fleming
- Kevin Fleming on LinkedIn
- Kevin Fleming on YouTube
- Kevin Fleming on Facebook
- Kevin Fleming on Instagram
- Kevin Fleming on X
- Catapult
- The Entrepreneurial Mindset Advantage: The Hidden Logic That Unleashes Human Potential
- Do Schools Kill Creativity
- The World Needs You